My Info

REALTOR®

Caitlin McLain

Naperville - Downtown Office
55 S Main St, Suite 250 Naperville, IL 60540
Caitlin McLain Profile Photo
My Bio

About Caitlin McLain

Hi! I am Caitlin McLain and I consider myself a boutique Realtor. I prefer to work with fewer clients and provide them with superior service. I try to be available to my clients 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. I maintain a flexible schedule, so when your dream house comes on the market we can move quickly. I am a full-time & full-service Realtor, working with all of my clients from beginning to end. All my clients get 100% of my attention, in fact some clients joke that they don't believe that I actually have a life outside of real estate. Rest assured any person you refer to me to will have all of their real estate goals completed with the care they deserve. Every client is treated like a million-dollar client, nothing will ever be as important as your home!
I was born and raised in the Naperville area. When I started in real estate over 12 years ago I was living in Wheaton, which is why I have sold the most houses there. However, I have now sold real estate all over the western suburbs. Currently I live in Lisle with my supportive husband, rambunctious sons, and my three sweetheart dogs. Just last year, we sold our second home and purchased our forever home to be closer to my family in Naperville. Because of this I feel uniquely qualified to help transition sellers who are looking to purchase their forever home. I mainly work in DuPage County, focusing on Naperville, Wheaton, Winfield,  Lisle, Glen Ellyn, Bolingbrook, & Aurora. I am available at 630.484.7289 through text or call and email at cmclaim@coldwellhomes.com for your complimentary consultation today!
In recent years I have earned multiple awards in client services and production volume. I had the honor of winning distinguished Best of Wheaton Award for Small Business of the Year in the Home Services Category. I have been named a Five Star Professional of the Year by Chicago Magazine in the Real Agent Category every year since 2017. In 2022 I was ranked among the top 1% of all realtors for closed sales production in our local MLS. In 2023 I was in the top 2% for closed sales production. In 2024 & 2025, I was in the top 250 agents of closed sales volume in all of DuPage County.
At the end of the day, I love my family, selling houses, and ALL dogs!!
Testimonials

What my clients are saying

Brent W.

Had my hand held through the whole process. Taking a layer of stress off during a time full of it.

August 29, 2026
Paul C.

Caitlin's passion for real estate came through in every interaction. She is extremely knowledgeable, very supportive and has a great sense of humor. I enjoyed working with Caitlin to purchase my new home. I highly recommended her.

August 26, 2026

I had a good experience working with Caitlin McLain. She was very giving of her time. She never rushed or pressured me. She was clearly my advocate in the process. Also important were the people she recommended: lawyer, inspector, lender, all highly competent. My transaction did not go as smoothly as it could have which I believe was largely due to the lack of urgency and responsiveness from the selling party. Again, Caitlin was a good advocaite throughout all of this. I recommend her!

June 18, 2026
Jfarina

Caitlyn is the best. Open honest and direct!

June 18, 2026
Edward F.

Caitlin is the best. Open honest and direct! After being in our residence for 33 years there was a need to downsize and on recommendation of our daughter we used Caitlin McLain to purchase our future home and list our current home. This was hard due to the years that we were in our residence, the memories, neighbors, and moving from 3,200 Sqft. to 1,500 Sqft. When all is said and done with Caitlin efforts and guidance, knownledge of the market, and the staging of our residence. We were able to list our home and have a full cash offer for our asking price within 4 hours of it coming on the market. With only a few bumps in the road the house was sold and closed 6/15/2026 and we are not settling into our new home and updating it to be ours. Many thanks to Caitlin and her efforts to make this happen with as little stress as possible.

June 16, 2026
Roxanne R.

We had a wonderful experience with Caitlin both selling our home and helping us purchase our new home. She works incredibly hard for her clients and is knowledgable, patient, personable, and makes the entire process as seamless as possible. We had complete confidence that she was prioritizing our best interests and her communication was always direct, timely, and transparent. We would absolutely work with her again!

May 12, 2026
Caitlin McLain

Listings

916 Lacey Avenue Property Photo 1
NewOpen House 9/12
$365,000
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
3bds 2ba1,410sqftActive
916 Lacey Avenue, Lisle, IL 60532
MLS #: 12754608
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $500,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    3bds 2ba1,296sqftClosed
    820 Cherry Street, Wheaton, IL 60187
    MLS #: 12564792
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $365,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    2bds 3ba1,582sqftClosed
    1269 Rhodes Lane, Naperville, IL 60540
    MLS #: 12607652
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $400,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    3bds 3ba1,400sqftClosed
    30w130 Huntington Drive, Warrenville, IL 60555
    MLS #: 12612374
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $750,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    4bds 3ba3,264sqftClosed
    2001 Lakeview Court, Naperville, IL 60565
    MLS #: 12646404
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $450,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    4bds 2ba1,790sqftClosed
    5324 Clover Drive, Lisle, IL 60532
    MLS #: 12623999
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $450,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    3bds 2ba1,844sqftClosed
    1018 Dawes Avenue, Wheaton, IL 60189
    MLS #: 12647681
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $120,000
      Home Title Group Logo
      0.28 acre lot$428,571/AcreClosed
      512 Pershing Avenue, Wheaton, IL 60189
      MLS #: 12275376
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $439,900
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      3bds 2ba1,102sqftClosed
      1020 S Gables Boulevard, Wheaton, IL 60189
      MLS #: 12687150
      Keller Williams Premiere Properties
      $495,000
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      3bds 3ba2,109sqftClosed
      928 Shandrew Drive 928, Naperville, IL 60540
      MLS #: 12659887
      john greene, Realtor
      $235,000
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      2bds 2ba1,080sqftClosed
      666 Sundance Drive, Bolingbrook, IL 60440
      MLS #: 12706333
      1% Lists Real Estate Solutions
      $300,000
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      3bds 2ba1,403sqftClosed
      2s739 Grove Lane, Warrenville, IL 60555
      MLS #: 12589535
      MAIN STREET REAL ESTATE
      $450,000
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      3bds 3ba1,741sqftClosed
      6385 Winstead Court, Lisle, IL 60532
      MLS #: 12542803
      Platinum Partners Realtors
      $359,900
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      4bds 2ba1,775sqftClosed
      1914 Clinton Avenue, Berwyn, IL 60402
      MLS #: 12490118
      Realty of America, LLC
      $649,900
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      4bds 3ba2,021sqftClosed
      321 Carriage Hill Road, Naperville, IL 60565
      MLS #: 12571583
      Coldwell Banker Realty
      $445,000
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      3bds 3ba1,938sqftClosed
      1015 Confederation Drive, Bartlett, IL 60103
      MLS #: 12592678
      Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Starck Real Estate
      $475,000
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      4bds 3ba2,096sqftClosed
      27w160 Oakwood Street, Winfield, IL 60190
      MLS #: 12655702
      Southwestern Real Estate, Inc.
      $350,000
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      3bds 2ba1,510sqftClosed
      1106 Pheasant Trail, Carol Stream, IL 60188
      MLS #: 12551737
      RE/MAX Suburban
      $575,000
      Midwest Real Estate Data IDX Logo
      5bds 3ba1,750sqftClosed
      1518 Center Avenue, Wheaton, IL 60189
      MLS #: 12669135
      Realty Executives Premier Illinois